En 200
Goleman & Sampson
Assignment 1: due Sept. 9
Read: Living Literature, Introduction pp. 1-5; pp. 11-26
Plot in “The Story of an Hour” and “Under the Radar”
In his discussion of plot, John Brereton writes, “Plot is how the story gets told by the storyteller’s artful shaping . . . [T]he same basic story . . . can give rise to many different plots” (15).
After you have read the assigned pages, do this:
.
- Review Richard Ford’s story, “Under the Radar.”
- Draw a line down the middle of a notebook page in order to keep double-entry notes
- In the right-hand column, tell Ford’s story as you’d expect to see it reported in a local newspaper. Give the report the kind of headline you’d expect to see as well.
- In the left-hand column, summarize the plot of Ford’s story, “how the story gets told by the storyteller’s artful shaping.”
- Write a paragraph in response to this question: What are the differences between the news report and Ford’s plot and what effect do you think these differences have on the impact or meaning of the story?
_______________________________________________________________________
En 200
Goleman and Sampson
Assignment 2: due Sept. 11
Read: LL, pp. 26-32, pp.70-71
Character and Symbol in “Stockings” and “Prue”
In his discussion of character, Brereton writes that “Short stories rely . . . on compression, focusing on a single salient detail to reveal character” (29). Brereton also refers to something Henry James, the nineteenth century American writer, observed about the close link between plot and character when he asked, “What is incident but the illustration of character” (26)?
Please read the assigned pages once. Then to examine for yourself the way character is shaped by detail and incident in fiction, do this:
- Review Tim O’Brien’s story “Stockings” and Alice Munro’s story, “Prue.”
- Set-up a page for keeping double-entry notes.
- In the right-hand column, choose one “salient detail” and one incident from each story that you think illustrates character. Quote the passages (4 total) and note page numbers.
- In the left-hand column, explain each of your selections fully and thoughtfully. What does it illustrate about a character in the story that you think is important? Does the detail or incident you have chosen also have symbolic meaning? If so, what?
__________________________________________________________
Goleman and Sampson
Assignment 3: due Sept. 16
Read: LL, pp. 32-47
Setting in “Araby” and “Mary’s Convert”
Brereton writes, “The setting, the time and place where the story happens, can have a powerful influence on how we understand it.” This may be true, but still it’s no secret that readers sometimes skip descriptions of setting, finding them boring.
Please read the assigned pages once. Then, to examine for yourself what the power of setting may or may not be, do this:
- Review James Joyce’s “Araby” and Cyrus Colter’s “Mary’s Convert”
- Set up a page for keeping double-entry notes.
- In the right-hand column, choose two passages from each story that depict setting (4 total). Quote them and note page numbers.
- Use the left-hand column to explore these questions: How does each of these descriptions of setting influence your understanding of the story? Would you defend an editor who told the author to cut the passage? Why or why not?
____________________________________________________
En 200
Goleman and Sampson
Assignment 4: due Sept. 18
Read: LL, pp. 48-56, 86-89
Point of view and Tone in Jamaica Kincaid’s “Girl” and Margaret Atwood’s “Happy Endings”
Brereton writes that point of view is “the perspective from which a story is told” (48). He goes on to say, “Often the teller can matter as much as the tale itself, since there is always a relationship between the events in the story and the actual way they are presented” (48).
Please read the assigned pages once and then do this:
- Review “Girl” and “Happy Endings.”
- Set up a page for keeping double-entry notes.
- In the right-hand column, choose two passages from each story where the point of view of the narrator stands out to you in some way—where you think the teller matters as much as the tale. Quote them and note pages numbers.
- In the left-hand column, say why you have chosen each passage, who you imagine is narrating and what this person’s attitude is toward the story.
- If you are confused by any of these passages, try to explain your confusion. Ask questions in left-hand column.
.
__
En 200
Goleman and Sampson
Assignment 5: due Sept.23
Read: LL, pp. 57-64
Theme in “A&P”
Brereton writes, “Once you have noted a theme in a story, you are off to a good start, but you are closer to the beginning, not the end of your discussion” (63). To build on this point, he goes on to paraphrase the writer Flannery O’Connor arguing that “meanings are not neat little messages to be abstracted or drawn from stories” (64). To begin testing the uses and limitations of theme-finding, do this:
- Look at Brereton’s list of three possible themes about Updike’s story, “A&P,” on p. 63.
- Review “A&P.”
- Choose one of these themes that you want to work with and write it on the top of a notebook page. Write two or three solid paragraphs (6-10 sentences each) supporting this theme with specific reference to the story. Draw a line across the page when you have finished.
- Now, say what you think this theme leaves out, oversimplifies or just doesn’t get. You can use the elements of fiction that we have been studying to help you notice more in the story. You can also explore your personal reaction to passages that might have impressed or irritated you for some reason and try to figure out why. You had this reaction. Don’t hold back here. Generate as much additional commentary as you can. It’s okay to jump around and not connect your ideas. In this section, we are asking you to explore for yourself why Brereton would say that themes may be a place to begin, not end, your discussion of a story.
_________________________
______________________________________________
Assignment 6
Due Sept. 30: “A&P” paper for grading: typed, titled and proofread
Suggested length: 3-4 double-spaced, numbered pages
We have returned Assignment 5, your first attempt to analyze a theme in “A&P” with our suggestions for taking it further. For Tuesday, you should revise your work on “A&P,” turning it into an essay on the theme you have chosen to work with and its limitations. You can follow the format of Assignment 5:
- In the first section, name the theme you have chosen from Brereton’s options, say why you have chosen it, and support it as fully as you can with specific reference to the story.
- In the second section, we want you to examine why Brereton says, “Once you have noted a theme in a story, you are off to a good start, but you are closer to the beginning, not the end of your discussion” (63). You can examine this remark by asking yourself:
- What more is there to say about “A&P” that matters? Why is the theme a way to begin but not end an analysis of this story?
Choose one or two ways of adding to what you have already said, using the elements of fiction and your own reaction to the story to go beyond the theme. This can include a critique of the theme you have chosen. Aim for at least two pages in this section.
- In a concluding section, try to put the two sections of your paper into dialogue and ask yourself what you now understand about the story, “A&P” on the basis of writing the first and second sections. In this final section, you can think of yourself as telling the story of your own reading and writing process—where it has brought you. We are not looking for a quick answers here or mere happy endings, but more how and why.
Assessment Criteria:
- To receive an A or B, you need to have worked out a response to all three sections of the paper using full paragraphs that elaborate your points with detailed references to the story.
- To receive an A or B, you need to quote from the story accurately and to put page numbers in parentheses after a quote as illustrated above.
- To receive an A or B, you need to have successfully completed Assignment 5 and applied our feedback to Assignment 6. We are available for appointments to help you fulfill this criterion.
______________________________________________________
Assignment 7 due: Thursday, Oct. 2, typed
Read “The Third and Final Continent,” Jhumpa Lahiri, 448-461
Part 1
I like to think of that moment in Mrs. Croft’s parlor as the moment when the distance between Mala and me began to lessen.” (460)
With the above sentence, the narrator announces a turning point in the plot of Jhumpa Lahiri’s story, “The Third and Final Continent.” What exactly happens in this scene and how could it possibly lessen the distance between Mala and the narrator?
Part 2
Now look at the story in terms of form. Choose a passage that stands out to you as striking or important. Copy the passage word for word. Below the passage or in double-entry format, analyze the passage’s significance and identify the elements of fiction at play
______________________________________________________
Assignment 8
Due Tuesday, Oct. 7, typed
Read “Fiesta, 1980”: Junot Diaz
The descriptions of Yunior’s car sickness make for some pretty funny scenes that hold the plot together in “Fiesta, 1980.” But why does he throw up every time he rides in his father’s green van? That’s an unanswered question in this story.
To begin to build an answer this question, do this:
- Choose 5 passages in which the narrator talks about his father or interacts with him. Write out these passages in the right-hand column of double-entry notes.
- In the left-hand column, explain what each passage tells you about Yunior’s relationship to his father, how Yunior feels about him and what effect you think these feelings have on the boy.
Based on your work with these passages, generate a list that describes as fully as you can Yunior’s feelings toward his father.
__________________
Assignment 9
Due Thursday, Oct. 9
Read : “Her Mother” by Anjana Appachana, pp. 490-499
“Her Mother” is a gripping account of a transcontinental mother-daughter relationship. However, you may find it hard at times to pay attention to every word because the narrator is a nagging mother. But there’s a big pay-off for doing so and I encourage you to hang in there!
After you have read the story once, review and mark your book in two ways:
1. Bracket sections that represent clues to the mystery that you notice upon a second reading. Name the clues in the margins.
2. Put a star* next to at least 3 sections that provide insight into the character of the mother. Try to find sections that represent different sides of her character. Write words in the margins that represent her characteristics as revealed in each passage.
Note: If you do not want to write in your book, you can use post-its. We will give you credit for this homework by asking you to show us your work in your book.
________________________________________________
Assignment 10: Paper on two immigrant stories
Draft due for Peer Review: Tuesday, Oct. 14
Draft due for Teacher Review: Thursday, Oct. 16: Typed, Titled and Proofread
(Students who do not attend peer review with a full draft forfeit the chance to revise after teacher review. Sending the draft electronically while missing class will not fill this requirement.)
Critics complain that sometimes writers offer oversimplified or one-dimensional representations of the immigrant experience in terms of plot, character, incident, point of view, symbolism or theme. However, our class discussions on “The Third and Final Continent,” “Fiesta, 1980” and “Her Mother” have (I hope) demonstrated that there is much in them that offers powerful, unexpected, multi-dimensional insights on the experiences of immigrants in America and their families.
- Choose two of the three stories we have read. In each case, say what stands out to you as the most multi-dimensional, unexpected, powerful, odd or disturbing insights you take away from each these stories. Bring forward and discuss the specific passages and incidents that have led to your understanding.
- In a concluding section of at least one paragraph, look back at the insights you have named in terms of the elements of fiction that have produced them. What elements of fiction seem most responsible for the insights you have gained and why?
- Alternative Option for Concluding Section: Bring forward and discuss any parts of the two stories that you think oversimplify or offer a one-dimensional representation of the immigrant experience and say why. Be careful, however, not to choose passages that are purposely intended by the author to represent a character’s one-dimensional or stereotypical thinking.
_____________________________________
En 200
Assignment 11: due Tuesday Oct. 21
Read Chapter 20, Plays, 1159-1165
Reread Trifles, by Susan Glaspell, pp.1166-1180 (includes context and commentary)
This assignment invites you to transform part of the play, Trifles, into part of a short story in order to get a first-hand sense of how the two genres differ.
Please do this:
- Imagine how you would begin the short story version of Trifles and write about 500 words. Give your story a new title. You may use Glaspell’s dialogue as much as you want. We will not assess the quality of your fiction writing—only the completion of the assignment. Have fun with this. If you do it, you can’t do it wrong.
- Write a reflective section in which you explain what you had to do to turn the play into a short story: What for you are the most important differences between the genres and how do you think these differences affect understanding and meaning?
- Bring 4 copies of your short story version to class.
- WARNING: Do not read Glaspell’s own short story version before writing yours; it will ruin any chance you have for thinking this through for yourself and the likely consequence will be that you become blocked. We’ll read Glaspell’s own short story version next.
Note: If you want to turn Trifles into a complete short story, you can do this for extra credit.
______________________________________
En 200
Assignment 12: Due Thursday, Oct. 23
In Trifles, Mrs. Hale is a conventional law-abiding citizen by all appearances. However, through the course of the play, she changes to the point where she breaks the law by hiding evidence that could lead to the conviction of Mrs. Wright for murder. Go through the play and make a list of all the events that take place and all the statements by other characters that produce this change in Mrs. Hale.
Bring this list to class where it will be the basis for further analysis and writing.
_________________________________________
En 200
Assignment 13: Due Thurday, Oct 30
Read in LL: “From Avant-Garde to Contemporary Theater”, pp. 1857-1861
: Los Vendidos, by Luis Valdez, pp. 1868-1877
Please read Los Vendidos and make sure to read about El Teatro Campesino on page 1876. In that section, you will see a reference to an interview that playwright Luiz Valdez gave to Carl Heyward. In his introduction to that interview, here is what Heyward wrote:
El Teatro Campesino was the cultural wing of the United Farm Workers union, a popular theater that took its material directly from the lives of its audience in the bean fields of California’s central valley. With a pointed political mission, the theater, and its driving force, Luiz Valdez . . . remain true to its original vision: performance that addresses the Chicano experience in America.
For Thursday, do this:
--Select 4 passages where you notice the play’s “pointed political mission” in regard to the “Chicano experience in America.” Quote the passages in the right-hand column of double-entry notes and explain your selection in the left-hand column.
---Compose one or two questions that would help you to advance your understanding of this play by being addressed in class discussion.
_______________
_____________________________________________
En 200
Assignment 14: In-class essay exam on Tuesday Nov. 4 (open book)
Reread: Trifles and Los Vendidos
(no make-up exams will be given without a documented reason for absence)
The exam on Tuesday is meant to consolidate the work we have been doing recently on finding and forming relationships between texts. It is not meant to be tricky or hard and will consist of two questions:
Question 1 will cite a passage from each play. We will ask you to name a connection between these passages and to support the connection that you name specifically.
Question 2 will ask you to add a passage from each play that fits the connection you have made and to explain how these passages fit.
To prepare for the exam, I recommend rereading the plays, the introductory material to the plays by John Brereton and your own homework assignments. For all the differences between Trifles, a melodrama written in 1916, and Los Vendidos, a farce written in 1967— think about what they might be said to have in common.
Bring your book to class and a dark pen.You may also bring your homework to refer to,but this is not necessary and may not be helpful.
_________________________________________________
En 200
Assignment 15: Due Thursday, Nov. 6
Read the introduction to Poetry in Living Literature, pp 719-723, and do this:
• Underline two metaphors in Paul Laurence Dunbar’s poem, “We Wear the Mask,” besides the title metaphor.
• Skim the entire poetry section in LL. Choose a poem you like, for any reason whatsoever, type it up and bring it to class. You may choose instead to type up and bring to class a poem outside the text or even the lyrics of a song that you like.
En 200
Assignment 16: due Thursday, Nov. 13
Read in LL: Chapter 10, Poems: Tone and Image, pp. 724-741
To begin our study of poetry, read the above pages which introduce two of poetry’s key elements: tone and imagery. After you have read this section, choose 3 of the poems in it and reread them a number of times. In a double-entry format, do this:
• Select at least 4 lines each from two poems that you find interesting in some way. Do not choose poems that Brereton explains at length.
o In the right-hand column, copy the lines; in the left-hand column, analyze the tone and images in these lines as well as anything else you find interesting about them.
• Select lines or verses from one other poem that you find confusing or unclear in some way.
o In the right-hand column, copy the line or verse and in the left-hand column try to explain what confuses you or what you find unclear.
__________________________________________
Assignment 17: due Nov. 18
Read in LL: Chapter 11: Meter, Stanza, Form, pp. 755-767
To practice analyzing the meter, stanza and form of a poem do this:
• Read the assigned pages carefully
• Then read the following three poems: “Aunt Jennifer’s Tigers,” p. 770; “The World Is Too Much with Us,” p. 1029; “Facing It,” p. 1107-08; “Quinceanera,” p. 1113
• Using double entry notes, copy “Aunt Jennifer’s Tigers” and “The World Is Too Much with Us” in the right-hand column. Mark the meter and rhyme scheme. In the left-hand column, name meter and the rhythm scheme using the terms introduced on 755-67.
• Copy one of the two free verse poems in the right-hand column (“Facing It” or “Quinceanera”) Underline any shaping devices or patterns you notice that help to give form to the verse in the absence of traditional meter and rhyme scheme. In the left-hand column, describe the shaping devices or patterns you have underlined.
_________________________________________________
Assignment 18: due Nov. 20
Read in LL: Poetic Language, pp. 741-754
Choose three of the poems in the “For Further Reading” section, pp. 748-752, and make notes in your books that describe the poetic language devices you see. You should use the bold-faced terms that Brereton presents in the chapter.
Note: If you do not want to write in your books, please use post-its. We’ll give you credit for this homework at the beginning of class.
________________________________________________
Assignment 19: Draft of graded paper due for peer review, Tuesday, Nov. 25 (no revision option without a draft on 11/25)
Read in LL: from “How to Read a Poem: And Fall in Love with Poetry” by Edward Hirsch, pp. 806-807
Approximate length: 500-750 words
When you read the excerpt from “How to Read a Poem: And Fall in Love with Poetry,” you will see Edward Hirsch reviewing what various writers have said about the role of the reader in the creation of a poem’s meaning. Please read this excerpt a few times and mark passages that help you to think about yourself as a reader of poetry.
For your paper, we would like you to discuss the role of the reader in poetry based on passages from Hirsch that you find helpful. Then we would like you to perform the role of a reader in relation to the poem you have chosen. You should draw on the elements of poetry we have been studying to analyze your chosen poem. Finally, we would like you to look at the role you have played as a reader in terms of the ideas you brought forward from Hirsch’s essay and say what you notice.
Here, in short, are the three guiding questions that your essay should address:
• What do Hirsch and his sources say about the role of the reader in poetry? (based on selected passages)
• How do you read the poem you have chosen? (analyze your poem using the elements of poetry to build an interpretation)
• To what extent does your experience of reading and analyzing the poem confirm the ideas from Hirsch that you discussed and to what extent does your experience of reading and analyzing the poem prompt other ideas about the role of the reader?
Coming Up:
The final draft of this paper will be due on Dec. 4. We will ask you to bring copies of the poem and your paper for everyone in the class. No late papers will be accepted except for a documented emergency.
You will then have a collection of essays demonstrating “how to read” a set of poems. The final exam for the course will ask you to begin organizing the collection into chapters based on groups of poems that you think go together in some way. You will be asked to write an introduction to one chapter. In this way, you will complete our course in Understanding Literature by performing the role of literary editor that you have observed John Brereton perform in his anthology.
_____________________________________
Assignment 19
Paper due in class on December 4
Here are the guidelines for Assignment 19:
• Bring to class 29 collated and stapled copies of your poem and your paper
• Your papers and the copies are due at the beginning of class
• No late papers will be accepted (except for emergency)
• To save expense, you can single space and use both sides of page
• Give your paper a distinctive title
• Proofread your paper carefully for errors.
• When quoting Hirsch, put page numbers in parentheses after quote.
|